46 Million Uninsured Americans
46 Million “Americans” lack Health Insurance – Is It True?
It appears that the numbers of uninsured in America has been all hype. The 46 million are real but needs to be examined. They are not a homogeneous lot. Maybe you saw the gentle lady of the House representing an area of North Carolina (I think) who presented the truth about the uninsured to the House. Her speech placed the data in the Congressional record. It was really the first time I saw the data and am ashamed to say I had never before looked into it.
Previously, I presented a review of an article by Dr. David Gratzer on how to fix American medicine. He is a Canadian by birth but lives and works in the US now in a think tank and has written a book on how to fix things. He made a plea not to have socialized medicine like Canada etc. However, he also cited data about the 46 million uninsured in the US. That portion of his writing was ignored.
In an editorial, the INVESTOR’S BUSINESS DAILY (June 17) cites the Census Bureau numbers in their August report (Income, Poverty, and Health Insurance Coverage in the US). The same data was cited by the lady from North Carolina listed above. The paper cites the study which shows that 21% of the 46 million people without insurance in 2007 are not US citizens. We don’t know how many illegal aliens were. The paper says it was appropriate to call the 46 million as uninsured but not Americans. Fully, one fifth was not US citizens. Yet, we are asked to pay for them too? The latest dollar figure for this is 1-2 trillion dollars over ten years. Baucus guarantees it will be under one trillion though.
The study also shows that 17 million of the uninsured make $50,000 a year or more. In fact, 7million of these earn over $75,000 a year. Dr Glatzer says they do not have insurance by choice. They are young and healthy and don’ feel vulnerable. These are the “non-poor uninsured.” There also many 18-34 year olds who are also healthy and refuse the cost of insurance. They use the money for other things.
Only about 19 million go without insurance for a full year, says the Census Bureaus’ study. Lack of insurance is a transitory thing because they lack overage only for a short time. Also there is a large contingent of people who are eligible for some federal health program like Medicare or Medicaid.
What it finally comes down to is that only about 8 million are really uninsured. Are you willing to pay 1-2 trillion dollars to provide coverage for them? That is what the talk show hosts are asking. Are we throwing out the baby with the bath water?

June 20th, 2009 at 6:10 pm
The article on the “actual” number of uninsured is largely irrelevant. Our health “system” (if it is a ’system’) produces results inferior to that of many other countries, and costs about twice as much. That’s the problem we need to fix. If the uninsured gain access to medical care as part of the fix, so much the better.