Strange News Stories

Friday, September 25th, 2009

Birth Defects – Do you think Abstaining Pregnant Women from Alcohol can Save the Baby?

Various birth defects affect 1 in every 33 babies born in the United States every year. These defects are the number one cause of infant death; figures indicate that they are responsible for a full 20% of the annual US infant mortality rate.

A birth defect can be categorized as a condition that the infant develops while still in utero. Most birth defects develop during the first trimester of a pregnancy, although a few may develop later.

A birth defect can affect the way the baby looks and/or the way its body functions. Some, such as a harelip or a club foot are easily visible well others such as a lack of sight or hearing may be harder to spot initially and are often not apparent until the child is a few weeks or even months old.

In the 21st century some of the most commonly diagnosed birth defects affect the heart. Some are mild enough to be treatable with medication and observation while others require immediate surgery to save the babies’ life.  The breakthroughs in infant cardiac surgery in the last twenty years ago have been astonishing, and skilled surgeons across the world are now able to save babies who years ago would have died very quickly.

Physical birth defects like these are hard to predict and in all likelihood the mother could have done nothing differently that would have prevented them from occurring. Some birth defects are related to the infants genetics but that too can be hard to uncover during pregnancy.

There are some birth defects though that are eminently preventable. A woman who smokes during pregnancy, even occasionally, has a greater chance of giving birth prematurely or to an infant with a low birth weight.

Alcohol consumption by pregnant women has also been linked with a number of birth defects that are collectively known within the medical community as fetal alcohol spectrum disorders. A baby born with FASD may have any one, or a combination of problems including problems with the heart, kidneys, or bones, hyperactivity, learning and speech difficulties and shorter-than-average height to name just a few.

There are those who believe that a small amount of alcohol can be safely consumed by pregnant women in their second and third trimesters but current medical thinking still predominantly advocates total abstinence for the entire course of the pregnancy.

For women who are over 35 there is also an increased risk that their baby may be born with a birth defect. Spina Bifida for instance, a condition that affects the spine and in many cases eventually causes death is found most commonly in infants whose mothers were older when they gave birth to them, although researchers have yet to conclusively decide why that should be the case.

9 Responses to “Birth Defects – Do you think Abstaining Pregnant Women from Alcohol can Save the Baby?”

Ohio Dad Says:

My family is living proof that this article is wrong. We are the proud parents of two healthy, happy children, and my wife drank a glass of wine a week with dinner, after the first trimester. Her OBGYN said that women are told not to drink, because many can not have “just one,” and it is not safe to get drunk. However, he said that one glass a week can help with lowering blood pressure and is perfectly safe for the mother and child.

Greg B. Says:

When my mom was with child,60 yrs ago, her doctor recommended she have a beer a day which was a common practice. Mom had four children and none of us have had any health problems as we are now in our 50’s and 60’s. I’m very courious why there are so many things we did in the past with no particular consequence to our health or well being that are now determined to be dangerous to our health. There are many other examples I could cite from my childhood that are taboo today. I’m not sure if all these taboos are for our medical well being or a way of doing some social engineering.

Annie G. Says:

The headline makes no sense. But everything in moderation has always been a good rule to follow. Must be a lot of drunks in Ohio for the OBGYN to say a woman could not have “just one”. As for Greg’s comment, most of it is social engineering. Computers don’t work well in smoke filled rooms.

Falon Says:

You did not mention in this article whether environmental factors, such as air and water quality, have an impact on pregnancy and prenatal development. For example, near my home in Indiana, we have a lot of confined feeding operations near waterways, which have contributed to unusually fast development (some girls are menstruating at 8-9) and has even caused an incident 11 years ago where the water was so contaminated with excess nitrates that there were cases of “blue baby syndrome.” Wouldn’t environmental factors such as this have a drastic impact on the likelihood of birth defects?

Alfred F. Says:

Two very interesting anecdotal articles. The prevalence of FASD is based on sound scientific study and does as a fact exist. (I have seen the devastating results.) Nothing is 100% and the two couples cited above are very lucky. There may be a threshold where occasional consumption of alcohol is safe, but why take a chance?

Valerie P. Says:

I didn’t drink a drop while pregnant, never smoked, took my vitamins, walked regularly, and did everything I was told to do and my child was born with two IVH’s, brain bleeds, considered birth defects. So, while I don’t advocate drinking at all while pregnant, this article does not prove birth defects can be avoided by abstaining from alcohol.

Prego mom Says:

I’m sure there are several of those, “My mom did it back in the day” stories. But now years later, they have done research and found what they considered healthy and ok back then, really wasn’t. Yes most babies are born ok, if the mother had one glass of wine. But as a pregnant person, I gave up smoking and drinking. I can do without it for 9 months if it means giving my child a healthy start. But I have also had 2 miscarriages so I’m willing to cut out caffeine and any other things that are not so much for the baby as they are for me.

Sheri R. T. Says:

My children are living proof that this article IS true. My children were adopted through the foster system, and it was well known that “Mom” imbibed occasionally. Both of my children suffer from various symptoms of Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder. It is also known that “Mom” did not drink while pregnant with an older brother. That child does not suffer these symptoms. My spouse and I have attended countless workshops and lectures on this subject and have done extensive study in order to help our children all we can. Scientific research is hard to pinpoint, however, since alcohol strikes so randomly. Some women can drink like the proverbial fish and their child is unaffected, while another woman had one drink on a particularly important developmental day and her child suffered. For instance it has been found that if the mother has an alcoholic drink on the 21st day of pregnancy, the child will most likely have some standard fetal alcohol facial characteristics. The symptoms themselves vary greatly. A child could be severely retarded with facial defects, or he could just be slightly delayed academically or socially. My own children’s symptoms are not identical, some are the same, some are widely different. They look and seem normal most of the time, but there are occasional glitches…Now that they are old enough to realize they are different in some way, it is agonizing to witness this realization and the isolation felt. It has been explained to them that it is not their fault, and what happened to bring them to this. Their first question was, “Why couldn’t she just not drink?” We explained to them that we honestly believe she didn’t know she was hurting them. All of this just for a glass of wine or a cold one? Are you sure you counted the days correctly? Will you be the mom who has the perfect child or the one that will bear the extra load? I feel it’s just not worth the risk. It’s not like a person cannot live without these libations for just 9 months. Why even take the chance? I really feel this needs to be more fully explained to the public, to those intending pregnancy most of all.

Doug T Says:

Lack of vision for the big picture (aka ignorance) always astounds me. “When we was kids we all ran across the ravine on that log so it was safe!” Until it fell and somebody else’s kid was killed.

Alcohol consumption does not ALWAYS WITHOUT FAIL cause defects in a fetus, so yes, there are healthy pabies whose mothers drank. But in indetectable instances it does. One of the results of Fetal Alcohol Syndrome is brain damage which inhibits the formulation of appropriate choices in maturity. Do you understand what this means? Studies show a HUGE majority of prison inmates are the children of mothers who drank.

Don’t be a fool: I’m not saying if you drink while preganant your baby will be a criminal. I’m not saying all criminals have FAS. But study after study shows that the impact of people with Fetal Alchol related difficulties on society is tremendous and costly, in education, medical, and social services. And IT IS THE ONE DEFECT THAT IS COMPLETELY PREVENTABLE. Just don’t drink while pregnant. Is it a risk you want to take? Can you be SURE that one glass of wine won’t be on the 21st day of your pregnancy when facial characteristics are affected? Can you be SURE it won’t be on the day that those brain synapses will form?

Or if you really need that drink, go ahead. It’s fetal roulette. And if you lose, you REALLY lose, because you will live with it for the rest of your child’s life.

Leave a Reply